Between tenants, a landlord or property manager should run the same lock sequence on every unit instead of deciding by habit. List every door, compare keys issued with keys returned, and check how each lock operates. Then decide door by door: keep the lock, repair it, or flag it because keys are still out. Finish with a written record of which keys went to the new tenant.
What to know before touching any lock
Start with a door list for the unit. Include the entry door, any second exterior door, and any interior door or storage lock that takes a key. Each lock gets its own line because each one gets its own decision.
Then compare keys issued with keys returned, door by door. Your move-in records show what you handed over. They don't show copies a tenant had cut on their own. If no record exists, treat the count as unknown. An unknown count weighs the same as a short one, because somewhere there may be a working key you can't account for. That missing key is what moves a door out of the keep column.
Note two more things for each door. The first is whether it belongs to a master key system, where one building key opens several locks that each also have their own key. Work on that lock alone can leave the master key unable to open it. The second is any problem the tenant reported, such as a key that stuck or a door that had to be pushed to lock.
Checking each lock while the unit is empty
Start with the door open. The key should slide in fully and turn without forcing, and the bolt should extend and retract all the way. From inside, try the thumbturn, the small knob on the inside of a deadbolt. It should move the bolt without catching.
Then close the door and lock it. Sometimes a bolt moves freely with the door open but drags once the door is closed. That usually points to how the door sits in the frame, not to the lock. Last, grip the knob, lever, and deadbolt housing. Any wobble means the mounting has worked loose.
A lock that works smoothly and sits solid on the door can stay. A key that needs jiggling, a latch that stops short, or a thumbturn that sticks marks the lock for repair before move-in. Worn finish on its own is cosmetic. Write down what you saw instead of taking the lock apart, so the notes describe the problem for whoever does the repair.
Deciding door by door: keep, repair, or flag
Whether a lock stays as it is after a tenant leaves is settled per door, not by one rule for the whole unit. Run the same questions in the same order for each lock. An early answer often settles the rest.
- Are all keys for this door back? If yes, the lock can stay keyed as it is. If not, or if the count is unknown, flag the door in the unit file as having keys outstanding. That flag is the deciding fact for this lock before the next tenant moves in.
- Did the lock pass the condition check? If yes, leave it. If it stuck, dragged, or wobbled, mark it for repair and restoration before move-in. If the hardware is cracked, note that too, so whoever looks at it knows what they are dealing with.
- Is the door on a master key system? If yes, any work on that lock has to fit the building's existing master arrangement.
- Will new copies be needed? If work is planned on the lock, cut copies only after it is finished.
How many keys to plan for the next tenant
Split the keys into two groups before cutting anything. One group is the set for the incoming tenant, usually one key per person who will live there. The other is the keys you keep for access and maintenance. Decide both numbers first so extra copies don't drift into a drawer.
Copy from a known good key, ideally the original rather than a copy of a copy, because small errors carry forward with each generation. Try each new key in its lock before handover. A key that barely turns at move-in becomes a problem later. Tag or number each copy so the record can say exactly which keys left your hands.
What to hand over and keep on file
Keep a short turnover record for each door in the unit file:
- The door and lock, named clearly enough that a stranger could find them
- Keys given to the tenant, by count and tag number
- The date of the lock check and what you observed
- Any work done on the lock, and when
- Who holds the spares, and how many
Have the new tenant confirm the key count at move-in. The next turnover then starts from a number both sides agreed on.
Safety Locksmith works on residential and commercial locks across Manhattan, including the Upper East Side, and in Long Island City. The work includes lock repair and restoration, key duplication, and master key systems. For lock work during a turnover, or a lockout while a unit sits between tenants, call (347) 666-4989.
Frequently asked questions
What if a former tenant never returned all of their keys?
A former tenant who kept a key leaves a working key outside your control, and possibly copies you never knew about. Getting one key back later does not settle the question, because it cannot show how many copies exist. Keep that door's count marked as unknown and decide what to do about that lock before move-in. Other doors in the same unit with full returns are judged on their own.
What should I do if a unit is part of a master key system?
A unit on a master key system needs that fact written into the unit file, so the next turnover starts with it. Count master keys separately from the tenant's unit keys, since master keys open more than one door. Any new unit keys should be cut only after lock work that fits the system is finished. Safety Locksmith works on master key systems.
What if I get locked out while preparing a unit for the next tenant?
A lockout during turnover usually means the only working key is still with the departing tenant or was left inside the unit. Safety Locksmith offers 24/7 emergency lockout assistance in Manhattan and Long Island City. Once you are back in, add that door to the turnover list and recheck its key count before the next tenant arrives.
